The Lemon Index

The Lemon Index · UK

UK MOT pass rates by car model.

Which used cars pass their MOT first time, compared with cars the same age. From 31,525,799 MOT tests in Great Britain in 2024.

31.5MMOT tests on cars and vans first registered 2004–2021
72.7%of cars passed first time
295models with 10,000+ tests
89% vs 57%cars first registered in 2021 vs 2004

Best and worst popular cars. MOT pass rate against cars the same age, models with 50,000+ tests.

Pass more than cars their age

  1. Mazda MX-5+10.4 pts
  2. Audi TT+9.6 pts
  3. Land Rover Range Rover+8.4 pts
  4. BMW 5 Series+8.0 pts
  5. Audi A6+7.7 pts
  6. BMW X5+7.2 pts
  7. Land Rover Range Rover Sport+7.0 pts
  8. Honda CR-V+6.7 pts
  9. Land Rover Defender+6.6 pts
  10. MINI Countryman+6.3 pts

Fail more than cars their age

  1. Citroen DS3−15.5 pts
  2. Renault Clio−12.0 pts
  3. Renault Megane−11.6 pts
  4. Citroen C4−10.9 pts
  5. Dacia Sandero−10.4 pts
  6. Peugeot 207−9.8 pts
  7. Dacia Duster−9.0 pts
  8. Vauxhall Mokka−6.9 pts
  9. Fiat Punto−6.9 pts
  10. Peugeot 2008−6.7 pts

Points = first-time pass rate minus the average for every car first registered in the same years. An MOT shows the car's condition on the test day, not how it will run tomorrow.

Vans and pickups. Against other vans the same age, 30,000+ tests.

Best

  1. Fiat Ducato+16.9 pts
  2. Peugeot Boxer+13.2 pts
  3. Volkswagen Transporter+6.0 pts
  4. Volkswagen Caddy+4.6 pts
  5. Mitsubishi L200+4.5 pts

Worst

  1. Vauxhall Vivaro−7.7 pts
  2. Renault Kangoo−7.3 pts
  3. Nissan NV200−6.9 pts
  4. Citroen Dispatch−6.8 pts
  5. Citroen Berlingo−6.4 pts

Vans do more miles and harder work than cars, so they get their own average. Van-based people carriers (Berlingo, Tourneo, Transporter) count as vans. Goods vans over 3,000 kg take a different MOT (class 7) that isn't in these numbers, so big vans like the Ducato, Boxer and Sprinter count only their lighter versions and motorhomes, which take the car MOT.

Why we compare cars with cars the same age. First-time MOT pass rate by year of first registration, every car.

  • 5704
  • 5705
  • 5606
  • 5707
  • 5708
  • 5909
  • 6010
  • 6211
  • 6512
  • 6713
  • 7114
  • 7415
  • 7816
  • 8117
  • 8318
  • 8619
  • 8820
  • 8921

Cars first registered in 2021 (3 years old, many on their first MOT) passed 88.8%; cars first registered in 2004 passed 56.7%. A model sold mostly as new cars would beat one whose cars are mostly old, whatever the build quality. So every score here compares a model with every car first registered in the same years, weighted by its tests.

Every model. Search, then tap a column to sort. The list scrolls.

295 models
Ford Fiesta1,369,92365.9%−4.568,1462004–2021
Ford Focus908,01468.8%−1.180,0272004–2021
Vauxhall Corsa904,05865.0%−6.263,8102004–2021
Volkswagen Golf841,20675.3%+4.283,8352004–2021
MINI Hatch632,05775.8%+3.961,6132004–2021
Vauxhall Astra623,27166.3%−1.985,4902004–2021
Volkswagen Polo605,08567.7%−3.764,6022004–2021
Nissan Qashqai571,99469.0%−5.471,2682007–2021
BMW 3 Series469,06476.1%+5.793,5512004–2021
Toyota Yaris423,61173.8%+3.161,1982004–2021
Audi A3417,76075.4%+3.985,9392004–2021
BMW 1 Series398,27776.0%+3.578,2162004–2021
Mercedes-Benz C-Class363,66174.7%+3.184,1222004–2021
Mercedes-Benz A-Class351,74478.9%+0.657,8432004–2021
Fiat 500333,57568.2%−4.452,7062008–2021
Honda Jazz331,31474.6%+6.259,7862004–2021
Nissan Juke314,35569.7%−5.959,5352010–2021
Renault Clio310,90757.4%−12.068,4482004–2021
Ford Kuga289,94779.5%+1.662,6512008–2021
Ford Transitvan287,34762.1%−1.0115,0922004–2021
Kia Sportage275,67676.3%−2.160,7722005–2021
Toyota Aygo261,24975.7%+2.250,8752005–2021
Volkswagen Transportervan261,03470.3%+6.0103,0872004–2021
Honda Civic254,50968.0%+0.887,9762004–2021
Hyundai i10246,84372.6%+0.147,2952008–2021
Audi A4245,63373.2%+3.5102,3452004–2021
Volkswagen Tiguan240,26682.0%+3.463,6002008–2021
Mercedes-Benz E-Class231,80077.7%+4.591,0792004–2021
Vauxhall Mokka231,09771.3%−6.954,3892013–2021
Skoda Fabia227,06670.7%−0.467,5482004–2021
Audi A1222,01177.0%+0.958,4382010–2021
Nissan Micra217,75265.2%−1.860,4902004–2021
Peugeot 208206,59270.9%−5.653,5262012–2021
BMW 5 Series202,24180.0%+8.0101,0412004–2021
Skoda Octavia201,13076.0%+2.296,6332004–2021
Vauxhall Insignia198,80168.1%−3.199,6182009–2020
Vauxhall Zafira195,48561.7%−4.692,5942004–2018
SEAT Ibiza192,43166.0%−6.568,8852004–2021
Citroen C3190,93765.0%−6.162,6982004–2021
Honda CR-V188,95875.4%+6.790,9662004–2021
SEAT Leon186,67676.8%+1.375,4502004–2021
Ford Mondeo186,07767.2%+0.1113,8112004–2021
Kia Picanto185,09770.8%−1.946,7172004–2021
Vauxhall Vivarovan184,21956.7%−7.7111,7162004–2021
Volkswagen Passat183,45871.6%+2.0118,8062004–2021
Citroen Berlingovan182,24658.8%−6.490,6042004–2021
Ford Ka176,72267.0%−1.454,9142004–2019
Citroen C1167,98869.5%+0.260,3362006–2021
Ford Transit Connectvan165,29465.7%−0.1101,2612004–2021
Land Rover Range Rover Evoque164,65782.4%+4.964,2682011–2021
Toyota Prius155,26378.0%+4.7133,1512005–2021
Renault Captur154,46677.8%−2.047,4922013–2021
Toyota Auris153,74172.5%+3.189,6822007–2019
Nissan Note152,44763.7%−1.476,2172006–2017
Peugeot Partnervan151,33762.3%−4.093,2482004–2021
Ford Transit Customvan146,90377.4%+0.963,2942018–2021
Volkswagen Caddyvan146,88568.5%+4.6108,3932004–2021
Peugeot 3008139,76271.3%−5.962,4592010–2021
Hyundai Tucson138,46282.7%−0.447,0332005–2021
Suzuki Swift135,23072.2%±0.060,3532005–2021
Peugeot 207134,82949.9%−9.886,1882006–2013
Peugeot 308132,25264.2%−6.681,2902008–2021
Peugeot 2008131,28573.8%−6.748,9842013–2021
Citroen C4130,50259.2%−10.982,1402006–2021
Audi Q3129,91083.4%+4.759,1012012–2021
BMW 2 Series128,95984.1%+2.549,3672014–2021
Hyundai i20128,83072.4%−0.457,8042009–2021
Land Rover Discovery126,47174.7%+4.8106,9832004–2021
Volkswagen up!126,10179.9%+4.846,5282012–2021
Ford C-MAX126,06466.9%−0.381,7932004–2019
Audi A5125,84478.1%+5.182,8902007–2021
Mazda 2125,77369.5%−0.662,2052005–2021
Audi A6123,95179.3%+7.7104,7692004–2021
Kia Ceed121,22267.0%−5.376,6862007–2021
BMW 4 Series118,51684.1%+4.560,3862013–2021
Land Rover Range Rover Sport118,39079.8%+7.082,7332005–2021
Land Rover Discovery Sport115,95081.6%−0.257,6032015–2021
Peugeot 107113,67862.1%+0.372,0842005–2014
Land Rover Freelander112,54165.8%+4.5117,5102004–2014
Volvo XC60112,45280.5%+3.174,7592009–2021
Audi Q5110,27283.8%+6.169,6372009–2021
Ford Rangervan108,71772.7%+3.177,2772004–2021
Mazda 3107,66068.7%−1.973,2932005–2021
Vauxhall Combovan107,09761.5%−5.085,2572004–2021
MINI Countryman106,64083.8%+6.353,2752010–2021
BMW X1106,35382.8%+4.961,2712010–2021
Dacia Sandero106,13569.0%−10.447,9102013–2021
Renault Traficvan105,60458.4%−6.3110,6732004–2021
Hyundai i30104,31764.8%−5.877,1532008–2021
BMW X3103,51479.9%+3.771,6102004–2021
Ford EcoSport102,51378.2%−4.039,0382014–2021
Audi TT100,02978.1%+9.673,6872004–2021
Renault Megane98,90754.0%−11.691,9982004–2020
Jaguar XF97,41574.5%+4.886,5502008–2020
Kia Rio96,61069.7%−2.562,8212007–2021
Toyota Corolla95,50576.5%+1.972,0222004–2021
Volvo V4095,31473.7%−2.670,3362012–2019
Vauxhall Meriva90,93663.1%−2.173,6602004–2017
Toyota RAV490,80882.0%+5.264,7492004–2021
Nissan X-Trail90,22670.5%−4.077,5612004–2021
Fiat Panda89,16164.6%−2.060,0242004–2021
Mercedes-Benz GLA87,49084.9%+2.547,2472014–2021
BMW X587,41979.8%+7.288,8602004–2021
Mercedes-Benz Vitovan85,88966.9%+2.0136,6122005–2021
Toyota C-HR84,64385.9%+0.440,8022017–2021
Mitsubishi L200van84,33969.3%+4.590,9402004–2021
Mercedes-Benz GLC78,20187.0%+3.249,3942015–2021
Mitsubishi Outlander77,92577.5%−0.177,9292007–2021
Land Rover Range Rover77,75779.2%+8.491,0662004–2021
Peugeot 10876,86082.1%+3.038,6102014–2021
Volkswagen T-Roc75,60991.0%+4.334,1402018–2021
Skoda Yeti75,13576.7%+4.872,7332010–2017
Volkswagen Touran73,30667.7%+0.6106,3362004–2021
Nissan Navaravan72,85368.2%+0.989,0642005–2021
Audi Q272,39990.3%+4.837,5072017–2021
Ford S-MAX72,27764.6%−3.0103,3022006–2020
Mercedes-Benz B-Class72,19272.7%+1.968,0882006–2021
Dacia Duster71,85872.2%−9.050,4192013–2021
Volvo XC4071,75390.2%+2.834,0122018–2021
Citroen DS371,75351.9%−15.579,8232010–2015
Kia Niro71,15087.5%+0.746,5562016–2021
Volvo XC9070,97073.9%+0.791,8642004–2021
Mazda MX-569,54677.2%+10.454,2262004–2021
Renault Kadjar68,96677.3%−4.650,8152015–2021
Vauxhall Grandland68,80385.6%−0.737,0572018–2021
Toyota Hiluxvan67,95569.9%+3.590,4002004–2021
Vauxhall Crossland66,82885.0%−1.532,0632017–2021
Mazda CX-566,33481.4%+1.659,7442012–2021
Land Rover Defender65,68274.8%+6.672,6242004–2021
Tesla Model 365,23883.7%−4.442,2252019–2021
Suzuki Vitara64,78185.6%+3.044,2602015–2021
Mercedes-Benz CLA64,55280.7%−1.156,5272013–2021
Skoda Superb62,43578.1%+0.292,2872010–2021
Mazda 659,83169.9%−0.691,5222006–2020
Vauxhall Adam58,98770.0%−5.751,0522013–2019
Toyota Avensis58,46966.7%+3.2121,2582004–2018
Fiat Punto58,13455.2%−6.979,6552004–2017
Ford Galaxy57,58763.7%−5.7112,9692005–2021
Fiat Ducatovan57,01476.7%+16.953,6812004–2021
Ford Puma55,01591.9%+3.525,1802020–2021
Jaguar F-Pace54,05885.0%+1.350,5972016–2021
Ford B-MAX53,70670.2%−1.954,6912012–2017
Renault Kangoovan53,57354.4%−7.395,8872004–2021
Peugeot Expertvan53,30867.0%±0.096,2372006–2021
Skoda Karoq52,43989.4%+3.136,5592018–2021
Skoda Citigo52,07979.3%+4.148,3882012–2019
Hyundai ix3551,35464.9%−3.687,2842010–2015
SEAT Arona49,73885.2%−1.331,8522018–2021
Audi Q748,75681.8%+7.183,2392006–2021
Ford Fusion47,33158.8%+1.085,9572004–2011
Kia Venga47,22172.2%−0.454,0082010–2019
SEAT Ateca47,10588.2%+3.443,5542016–2021
Mercedes-Benz SLK46,08372.7%+9.566,3872004–2016
Suzuki Alto46,00066.2%+0.359,2712005–2015
Fiat Doblovan45,33263.9%+1.283,9162005–2021
Volkswagen Scirocco45,18968.9%+0.891,8282009–2017
Citroen Dispatchvan44,60959.9%−6.899,0572007–2021
Nissan Leaf44,35680.9%−1.743,9512013–2021
Hyundai Kona44,26087.0%−0.231,4282018–2021
Peugeot Boxervan43,61775.5%+13.257,7972004–2021
Hyundai Ioniq43,56286.5%+0.657,7562017–2021
Jaguar XE42,96981.0%+1.260,3122015–2020
Smart (Mcc) Fortwo41,68072.9%+3.550,4032007–2019
MG ZS41,58883.9%−3.430,2372018–2021
Volvo V6039,81578.0%+1.081,0362011–2021
Vauxhall Viva38,27782.2%+2.637,1992015–2019
Suzuki SX437,99970.2%±0.068,7402007–2019
Skoda Kodiaq36,93588.0%+2.547,1162017–2021
Volkswagen Touareg36,25376.8%+3.988,8172005–2021
Volkswagen Beetle35,98158.5%−5.679,9052004–2017
Fiat 500X35,89175.6%−4.150,8682015–2021
Ford Grand C-MAX35,70267.3%−5.379,8412011–2019
Isuzu D-Maxvan34,78870.9%+1.777,5652012–2021
DS DS 334,67868.5%−11.349,0952015–2021
Renault Scenic34,60355.5%−8.985,8402006–2017
Peugeot 500834,58369.9%−9.463,6022010–2021
Porsche 91134,04990.3%+21.844,5052004–2021
Kia Sorento33,67771.5%−2.277,1622006–2021
Saab 9-333,67063.2%+5.4115,9912004–2011
BMW Z432,56377.8%+12.666,5732004–2021
Vauxhall Agila32,23261.8%−0.162,4222004–2014
Volkswagen Sharan32,08279.0%+1.399,1422011–2021
Jaguar E-Pace31,37887.7%+1.938,7442018–2021
Nissan NV200van31,26959.3%−6.982,2042010–2021
Mercedes-Benz GLE30,88787.3%+3.851,9972015–2021
Volvo V7030,81564.7%+4.0135,1572004–2015
Lexus CT30,78083.3%+10.076,7672011–2020
Land Rover Range Rover Velar30,31983.9%−1.046,1202017–2021
Honda HR-V30,12188.5%+6.844,1322015–2020
Porsche Macan29,97290.8%+8.847,2072014–2021
Volvo V5029,05854.8%−4.5130,1952005–2012
Mitsubishi ASX28,94376.0%+1.871,0612010–2020
Jeep Renegade28,81575.4%−4.454,8572015–2021
Mercedes-Benz M-Class (ML)28,76573.0%+9.2107,2192004–2015
Hyundai ix2028,55570.6%−2.451,4612011–2019
Peugeot 20628,54453.5%−3.283,7382004–2008
Citroen C3 Aircross28,48985.1%−0.831,4672018–2021
Hyundai Santa Fe28,47667.4%−3.187,3502006–2019
Lexus NX27,99389.9%+6.744,3292015–2021
Suzuki Celerio27,53284.6%+5.738,9622015–2019
Ford Transit Couriervan27,06970.3%−2.176,7762014–2021
Suzuki Ignis27,02982.7%+1.534,9872004–2021
Toyota Verso26,88571.0%+2.592,4292009–2017
Vauxhall Vectra26,76854.3%−2.8118,6422004–2009
Volkswagen Fox26,02051.6%−6.978,5352006–2011
Kia Stonic25,78388.0%+1.731,2232018–2021
Porsche Cayenne25,68285.8%+10.171,6342004–2021
Toyota Rav-425,52165.8%+5.9109,8182004–2014
Mazda CX-325,42585.4%+3.743,3732015–2019
Peugeot 30724,88948.8%−8.0101,6272004–2008
MINI Clubman24,85381.9%+2.053,4392015–2018
Land Rover R24,23787.9%−0.130,6352019–2021
Alfa Romeo Giulietta23,76266.8%−1.987,1412010–2017
SEAT Alhambra23,62476.8%−0.194,7092011–2019
Volkswagen T-Cross23,42489.4%+1.726,2002019–2021
Kia Soul23,34769.8%−0.368,5722009–2021
BMW i323,34087.1%+3.938,7372014–2021
Mitsubishi Shogun22,33066.8%+1.3101,0552004–2021
Citroen Xsara21,80149.9%−7.2101,7552004–2010
Skoda Rapid21,64873.6%−1.678,4332013–2018
Volvo C3021,57258.2%−1.8103,1492007–2012
Renault Twingo21,54761.0%−6.260,7422008–2017
Smart (Mcc) Forfour21,38574.4%−4.840,9262015–2019
Mercedes-Benz CLS21,37673.4%+5.493,1902006–2019
BMW 6 Series21,28279.9%+10.282,8082004–2019
Mitsubishi Colt21,23553.9%−4.683,3272005–2012
Nissan Pulsar21,05772.9%−4.357,8792014–2018
Honda Accord20,76360.3%+2.3129,8032004–2012
Renault Zoe20,67778.4%−6.929,8352015–2021
MG 320,58775.8%−5.937,2392014–2021
Citroen C4 Cactus20,57973.0%−9.545,8962016–2020
Volkswagen Amarokvan20,46776.4%+7.991,1972012–2020
Mercedes-Benz CLK20,39060.7%+3.6104,5242004–2009
Jaguar X-Type20,25858.1%+0.9108,4212004–2009
Hyundai i4020,09071.9%−1.297,3102012–2018
Citroen Grand C4 Picasso19,73167.0%−11.366,5402009–2021
Mercedes-Benz Citanvan19,51560.3%−8.798,4972013–2020
Peugeot Bippervan19,14657.6%−2.2107,5812009–2017
Fiat 500L19,06062.5%−8.272,0962013–2016
BMW X218,95985.2%−0.937,8092018–2021
SEAT Mii18,58577.6%+2.949,7232012–2021
Skoda Roomster18,01765.3%+1.284,6312007–2015
Alfa Romeo Mito17,94661.4%−3.678,8262009–2016
Hyundai Getz17,86453.8%−3.077,6272004–2008
Suzuki Splash17,55362.5%−1.560,8702008–2014
Suzuki Grand Vitara17,42161.9%+3.090,5052004–2013
Abarth 59517,31380.3%−2.235,4782015–2021
Mercedes-Benz S-Class17,23485.5%+10.383,8902006–2019
Vauxhall Antara17,18455.3%−12.584,5352012–2015
Jaguar I-Pace17,08592.2%+4.534,6562019–2021
Peugeot 50817,01970.9%−2.193,8752011–2021
Renault Grand Scenic16,83951.5%−12.9100,9732007–2017
Porsche Boxster16,76885.1%+21.758,9462004–2018
BMW X416,57685.1%+2.554,8112015–2021
Mercedes-Benz Sprintervan16,34773.8%+9.8127,3232007–2020
Volvo S4016,11557.4%−1.2110,5322004–2012
Toyota iQ16,04474.7%+13.670,6202009–2013
Lexus RX15,99691.6%+11.755,1332013–2021
Citroen C515,85776.3%−3.355,8042008–2020
Fiat 500C15,69965.7%−4.554,2032010–2017
Audi A715,53884.0%+9.884,8182011–2019
Volvo S6015,53372.5%+2.999,7522004–2020
Volkswagen ID.315,41090.0%+1.527,8062020–2021
Skoda Kamiq15,31889.0%+0.625,3962020–2021
Volvo XC7015,15370.1%+5.6120,3332005–2016
Volvo V9015,05984.5%−0.356,5582017–2021
Mazda CX-3014,40591.7%+3.224,5602020–2021
Dacia Logan14,30069.5%−9.073,4602014–2019
Kia XCeed14,14986.8%−1.628,1452020–2021
Chevrolet Spark13,96355.2%−8.668,5002010–2013
Jaguar F-Type13,84690.5%+12.232,5742013–2021
Lexus IS13,73186.8%+11.080,7592013–2019
Audi E-Tron13,63289.8%+1.633,6422019–2021
Volkswagen Cc13,35973.0%+2.5104,1082012–2016
Ford Tourneo13,31772.5%−7.0108,3782014–2019
Ford Tourneo Connectvan13,29578.6%+6.251,4042015–2021
Fiat Tipo12,95872.7%−10.151,0662016–2021
Citroen Nemovan12,78558.0%−1.0102,7142009–2016
Lexus UX12,60993.8%+6.128,8722019–2021
SEAT Altea12,47458.3%−2.0111,4012006–2013
BMW X612,15884.1%+6.569,7462012–2021
Jaguar XJ12,12374.6%+12.397,0002004–2016
Mitsubishi Eclipse12,08085.8%+0.538,2142018–2021
Kia Carens12,02966.7%−7.475,8652009–2018
Ford Mustang11,98984.8%+1.029,4192016–2021
Toyota Estima11,96578.6%+12.892,8252008–2017
MG HS11,56689.4%+0.826,5932020–2021
Nissan Pixo11,02363.5%+2.863,0042009–2012
Peugeot Rcz10,58164.9%−1.072,1132010–2015
Citroen C210,43552.8%−4.483,9082004–2009
Renault Modus10,42849.9%−8.076,6872005–2011
Suzuki Jimny10,38266.5%+4.371,1182004–2019
Mercedes-Benz V-Class10,32381.5%−0.2105,7172015–2019
Mitsubishi Mirage10,27680.5%+4.944,4022013–2019
Citroen DS410,15055.3%−12.491,0002011–2015

295 models with 10,000+ tests in years that have 1,000+ tests each; 114 have their own page. “vs same age” = the model's first-time pass rate minus the average for every car (or van) first registered in the same years, weighted by its tests.

What cars fail on. Share of car tests with a fail in each area.

  • Lights and electrics10.2%
  • Suspension8.4%
  • Tyres6.6%
  • Brakes6.3%
  • Windscreen, wipers and mirrors4.3%
  • Body, chassis and underside2.9%
  • Emissions, noise and leaks2.9%
  • Steering1.8%

A test can fail in more than one area. Lights and electrics are mostly bulbs; tyres are mostly tread under the 1.6 mm legal limit; “body, chassis and underside” also covers exhaust pipes, driveshaft (CV) boots and engine mounts.

Questions

Which used cars have the best MOT pass rate in the UK?

Against cars the same age, among models with 50,000+ tests in 2024: the Mazda MX-5 (+10.4 points), the Audi TT (+9.6 points), the Land Rover Range Rover (+8.4 points), the BMW 5 Series (+8.0 points), the Audi A6 (+7.7 points).

Which cars fail their MOT most?

Against cars the same age, among models with 50,000+ tests: the Citroen DS3 (−15.5 points), the Renault Clio (−12.0 points), the Renault Megane (−11.6 points), the Citroen C4 (−10.9 points), the Dacia Sandero (−10.4 points). An MOT shows the car's condition on the test day, not how it will run tomorrow. A low pass rate is not proof that a model is unreliable.

Is the Toyota Avensis good on MOTs?

Yes, against cars its age. 66.7% of Avensis cars passed first time in 58,469 tests, 3.2 points better than cars first registered in the same years, even though they averaged 121,258 miles at the test (same-age cars: 92,297).

Why compare cars with cars the same age?

Because age matters more than anything. Cars first registered in 2021 passed 88.8% of their 2024 MOTs first time; cars first registered in 2004 passed 56.7%. A model sold mostly as new cars would look good next to one whose cars are mostly old, so each model is compared with every car first registered in the same years.

What do cars fail their MOT on most?

Across cars first registered 2004–2021: lights and electrics (10.2% of tests), suspension (8.4% of tests), tyres (6.6% of tests), brakes (6.3% of tests).

Where does this data come from?

DVSA's anonymised MOT tests and results: every MOT test carried out in Great Britain in 2024, published free under the Open Government Licence v3.0. The scores are our own analysis, not DVSA's.

How to read this. An MOT shows the car's condition on the test day, not how it will run tomorrow. It counts what a tester found that day, and some of it (tyres, bulbs, wipers) is down to how a car was looked after, not how it was built. So we only compare a model with cars first registered in the same year, and we show the test count and the reasons cars failed. A low MOT pass rate is not proof that a model is unreliable.

Method. Every class 4 (cars and light vans) normal MOT test carried out in Great Britain in 2024 with a result of pass, fail or PRS (fixed at the test centre within an hour), one row per test. First-time pass rate = tests passed outright, out of all of them. PRS counts as a fail because the car arrived failing (this is DVSA's own “initial failure rate”, turned around). Trim and engine names are merged into one model (“FIESTA ZETEC” and “FIESTA” are both the Fiesta). Year = year of first registration in the UK, not the year the car was built. A year needs 1,000+ tests to be shown. Vans, pickups and van-based people carriers are compared with other vans. Northern Ireland isn't in this data.

Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0. Source: DVSA anonymised MOT tests and results.

Spot a mistake or have an idea?

How can we make Lemon Index better?