The Lemon Index

UK MOT pass rates · BMW

BMW 5 Series MOT pass rate.

BMW 5 Series cars first registered 2004–2021 passed 80.0% of their MOTs first time in 2024: 8.0 points better than cars the same age.

80.0%passed their MOT first time (202,241 tests in 2024)
+8.0 ptsvs cars first registered in the same years (72.0%)
101,041average miles at the test (same-age cars: 72,917)
7.1%of tests failed on tyres, the top reason
Why they fail

Why BMW 5 Series cars fail their MOT. Share of tests with a fail in each area.

  • Tyres7.1%about the same as cars the same age (6.6%)
  • Lights and electrics5.5%0.5× the rate for cars the same age (10.6%)
  • Suspension5.4%0.6× the rate for cars the same age (8.7%)
  • Brakes3.0%0.5× the rate for cars the same age (6.5%)
  • Windscreen, wipers and mirrors2.6%0.6× the rate for cars the same age (4.4%)
  • Emissions, noise and leaks1.5%0.5× the rate for cars the same age (3.0%)
  • Steering1.2%0.6× the rate for cars the same age (1.8%)

BMW 5 Seriescars first registered in the same years

A test can fail in more than one area. Each share counts tests with at least one fail or PRS defect there. “Body, chassis and underside” also covers exhaust pipes, driveshaft (CV) boots and engine mounts.

The most common fails. The exact items testers wrote down.

  1. Tyre tread below the 1.6 mm legal limit2.3% of tests (4,712) · DVSA wording: “tread depth below requirements of 1.6mm”
  2. Tyre cut to, or showing, its cords2.0% of tests (4,084) · 1.4× cars the same age · DVSA wording: “has ply or cords exposed”
  3. Broken coil spring1.9% of tests (3,887) · DVSA wording: “fractured or broken”
  4. Tyre cut to, or showing, its cords1.6% of tests (3,193) · DVSA wording: “has a cut in excess of the requirements deep enough to reach the ply or cords”
  5. Sidelight not working1.4% of tests (2,869) · 0.6× cars the same age · DVSA wording: “not working”
  6. Screen washer empty or not working1.0% of tests (2,014) · 0.7× cars the same age · DVSA wording: “provides insufficient washer liquid”

7.3% of BMW 5 Series tests found at least one “dangerous” defect (the car shouldn't be driven until it's fixed), against 7.9% for cars the same age.

Questions

Questions

What is the BMW 5 Series MOT pass rate?

80.0% of BMW 5 Series cars first registered 2004–2021 passed their MOT first time in 2024, from 202,241 tests. Cars first registered in the same years passed 72.0%, so the BMW 5 Series is 8.0 points better than cars its age.

Which BMW 5 Series years have the best MOT pass rate?

Against cars the same age: first registered in 2008, 71.3% (+14.2 points); first registered in 2009, 71.8% (+13.2 points); first registered in 2010, 72.9% (+13.0 points).

Why do BMW 5 Series cars fail their MOT?

The top areas: tyres (7.1% of tests), lights and electrics (5.5% of tests), suspension (5.4% of tests). The single most common item is tyre tread below the 1.6 mm legal limit (2.3% of tests).

How many miles has a BMW 5 Series usually done at its MOT?

101,041 miles on average at the 2024 test, across first registration years 2004–2021, against 72,917 for cars the same age.

Does the MOT pass rate tell me if a BMW 5 Series is reliable?

Not on its own. An MOT shows the car's condition on the test day, not how it will run tomorrow. Wear items like tyres, bulbs and wipers depend on the owner as much as the car. Comparing the BMW 5 Series with cars first registered in the same years takes age out of it, but always check the MOT history and service record of the exact car.

Which BMW 5 Series years to look for. Against cars the same age.

Years to look for

  • First registered in 2008: 71.3% passed first time, 14.2 points better than cars that age (6,858 tests)
  • First registered in 2009: 71.8% passed first time, 13.2 points better than cars that age (7,162 tests)
  • First registered in 2010: 72.9% passed first time, 13.0 points better than cars that age (8,411 tests)
  • First registered in 2007: 69.5% passed first time, 12.5 points better than cars that age (8,204 tests)

Years to be careful with

No year of the BMW 5 Series trails cars its age by a clear margin (2+ points).

Built only from the 2024 MOT results: a year is listed when its first-time pass rate is at least 2 points (and twice its margin of error) away from every car first registered that year. It's that year's record, not the history of any one car: check the MOT history of the exact car too.

MOT pass rate by year of first registration. 18 years with 1,000+ tests each.

  • 202187.0%−1.8 pts vs cars first registered in 2021 (88.8%) · 6,254 tests · 34,787 miles on average
  • 202088.8%+0.8 pts vs cars first registered in 2020 (88.0%) · 9,036 tests · 42,028 miles on average
  • 201988.1%+2.3 pts vs cars first registered in 2019 (85.8%) · 16,491 tests · 53,503 miles on average
  • 201887.1%+3.7 pts vs cars first registered in 2018 (83.4%) · 19,273 tests · 64,670 miles on average
  • 201785.5%+4.7 pts vs cars first registered in 2017 (80.8%) · 15,296 tests · 74,361 miles on average
  • 201685.4%+7.8 pts vs cars first registered in 2016 (77.5%) · 16,017 tests · 86,080 miles on average
  • 201584.2%+9.9 pts vs cars first registered in 2015 (74.3%) · 17,230 tests · 97,685 miles on average
  • 201482.1%+11.5 pts vs cars first registered in 2014 (70.6%) · 16,535 tests · 108,856 miles on average
  • 201376.9%+9.5 pts vs cars first registered in 2013 (67.3%) · 14,789 tests · 115,285 miles on average
  • 201273.4%+8.6 pts vs cars first registered in 2012 (64.8%) · 14,180 tests · 123,320 miles on average
  • 201173.1%+10.8 pts vs cars first registered in 2011 (62.3%) · 11,819 tests · 131,512 miles on average
  • 201072.9%+13.0 pts vs cars first registered in 2010 (59.9%) · 8,411 tests · 131,737 miles on average
  • 200971.8%+13.2 pts vs cars first registered in 2009 (58.6%) · 7,162 tests · 142,063 miles on average
  • 200871.3%+14.2 pts vs cars first registered in 2008 (57.1%) · 6,858 tests · 148,714 miles on average
  • 200769.5%+12.5 pts vs cars first registered in 2007 (57.1%) · 8,204 tests · 154,075 miles on average
  • 200667.8%+11.4 pts vs cars first registered in 2006 (56.4%) · 6,834 tests · 155,996 miles on average
  • 200567.9%+11.1 pts vs cars first registered in 2005 (56.8%) · 4,870 tests · 155,046 miles on average
  • 200465.1%+8.4 pts vs cars first registered in 2004 (56.7%) · 2,982 tests · 146,947 miles on average

BMW 5 Series first-time pass rateevery car first registered that year

Older cars fail more often, whatever the make, so the gray line moves from year to year. What matters is how far the bar sits from it. Green = 2+ points (and twice the margin of error) better than cars first registered that year, red = that much worse.

InfoData · how to read · feedback
How to read these numbers

How to read this. An MOT shows the car's condition on the test day, not how it will run tomorrow. It counts what a tester found that day, and some of it (tyres, bulbs, wipers) is down to how a car was looked after, not how it was built. So we only compare a model with cars first registered in the same year, and we show the test count and the reasons cars failed. A low MOT pass rate is not proof that a model is unreliable.

Method. Every class 4 (cars and light vans) normal MOT test carried out in Great Britain in 2024 with a result of pass, fail or PRS (fixed at the test centre within an hour), one row per test. First-time pass rate = tests passed outright, out of all of them. PRS counts as a fail because the car arrived failing (this is DVSA's own “initial failure rate”, turned around). Trim and engine names are merged into one model (“FIESTA ZETEC” and “FIESTA” are both the Fiesta). Year = year of first registration in the UK, not the year the car was built. A year needs 1,000+ tests to be shown. Vans, pickups and van-based people carriers are compared with other vans. Northern Ireland isn't in this data. The BMW 5 Series here merges these DVSA model names: 520, 5 SERIES, 530, 525, 535, 520D M SPORT MHEV AUTO….

Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0. Source: DVSA anonymised MOT tests and results.

Spot a mistake or have an idea?

How can we make Lemon Index better?