The Lemon Index
Porsche 911 Carrera

Should you buy a Porsche 911 Carrera?

  • Most owner complaints: the 2004 (15). Fewest: the 2000 (8). Raw counts, not per car sold, for every version NHTSA files under this name.
  • Budget for ims bearing failure: 13 owner complaints mention it. Aftermarket retrofit bearings exist; LN Engineering puts the job at about $2,000–3,500.
  • Budget for rear main seal leaks: 2 owner complaints mention it.
  • 1 recall campaign across 2000–2004 (all 911 versions). Check a VIN before you buy.

What owners say on YouTube

43This car's YouTube owner tone, out of 100 · #6 of 6 generations · videos about this generation only (the engine's tone above covers every car with that engine)

Owners praise

Handling and steering22%
Looks21%
Power and acceleration16%
Manual gearbox13%

Owners complain about

IMS bearing14%
PDK gearbox6%

Most-watched videos

  • New, the Carrera cost $69,300 (2005; destination not stated).
  • YouTube likes the 2006 best (51/100).
  • Budget for bore scoring: 1 owner complaint mentions it.
Sources
  1. PCNA release: Porsche details all-new 911 models for model year 2005 (May 2004, via The Auto Channel)

What owners say on YouTube

50This car's YouTube owner tone, out of 100 · #5 of 6 generations · videos about this generation only (the engine's tone above covers every car with that engine)

Owners praise

Handling and steering22%
Looks21%
Power and acceleration16%
Manual gearbox13%

Owners complain about

IMS bearing14%
PDK gearbox6%

Most-watched videos

  • New, the Carrera cost $75,600 (2009; destination not stated).
  • YouTube likes the 2012 best (53/100).
Sources
  1. Porsche release on the 2009 911 Carrera and Carrera S (June 2008, via Velocity Journal)

What owners say on YouTube

51This car's YouTube owner tone, out of 100 · #4 of 6 generations · videos about this generation only (the engine's tone above covers every car with that engine)

Owners praise

Handling and steering22%
Looks21%
Power and acceleration16%
Manual gearbox13%

Owners complain about

IMS bearing14%
PDK gearbox6%

Most-watched videos

  • New, the Carrera cost $82,100 (2012, excluding destination).
  • YouTube likes the 2016 best (57/100).
  • Most owner complaints: the 2013 (10). Fewest: the 2016 (2). Raw counts, not per car sold, for every version NHTSA files under this name.
  • 3 recall campaigns across 2012–2016 (all 911 versions). Check a VIN before you buy.
Sources
  1. PCNA: Porsche to unveil all-new 2012 911 Carrera (Aug 2011, PR Newswire)

What owners say on YouTube

54This car's YouTube owner tone, out of 100 · #2 of 6 generations · videos about this generation only (the engine's tone above covers every car with that engine)

Owners praise

Handling and steering22%
Looks21%
Power and acceleration16%
Manual gearbox13%

Owners complain about

IMS bearing14%
PDK gearbox6%

Most-watched videos

  • New, the Carrera cost $89,400 (2017; destination not stated).
  • YouTube likes the 2018 best (54/100).
  • 5 recall campaigns across 2017–2019 (all 911 versions). Check a VIN before you buy.
Sources
  1. PCNA: The sports car legend enhanced, the new 911 Carrera (Sept 2015, PR Newswire)

What owners say on YouTube

52This car's YouTube owner tone, out of 100 · #3 of 6 generations · videos about this generation only (the engine's tone above covers every car with that engine)

Owners praise

Handling and steering22%
Looks21%
Power and acceleration16%
Manual gearbox13%

Owners complain about

IMS bearing14%
PDK gearbox6%

Most-watched videos

  • New, the Carrera S cost $113,200 (2020, plus $1,050 delivery).
  • YouTube likes the 2022 best (64/100).
  • Most owner complaints: the 2022 (10). Fewest: the 2025 (1). Raw counts, not per car sold, for every version NHTSA files under this name.
  • 10 recall campaigns across 2020–2025 (all 911 versions). Check a VIN before you buy.
Sources
  1. PCNA: The new 2020 911 Carrera S and 4S (Nov 2018, PR Newswire)

What owners say on YouTube

62This car's YouTube owner tone, out of 100 · #1 of 6 generations · videos about this generation only (the engine's tone above covers every car with that engine)

Owners praise

Handling and steering22%
Looks21%
Power and acceleration16%
Manual gearbox13%

Owners complain about

IMS bearing14%
PDK gearbox6%

Most-watched videos

Updated