The Lemon Index

Planes · Single-engine piston

Piper J-3 Cub.

Every U.S. accident NTSB investigated, 2008 to 2025.

Piper J-3 Cub

Photos: The Smithsonian Institution (Wikimedia Commons)

136accidents
12%were fatal
22deaths
1%aircraft destroyed

What happened. NTSB's defining event, share of accidents.

Loss of control on ground21%
Loss of control in flight12%
Loss of engine power (partial)5%
Loss of engine power (total)4%
Nose over/nose down4%
Aerodynamic stall/spin3%

Pilot or plane? How often NTSB listed an aircraft problem among the causes.

22%the plane was part of the cause
engine, systems, structure or propeller
78%people or weather only
pilot decisions, control, fuel planning

Out of 89 accidents where NTSB recorded a cause. When the plane was a cause, it was most often the engine (reciprocating).

When. Phase of flight.

Landing25%
Initial climb15%
Approach15%
Takeoff14%
Enroute10%

Accidents per year.

200811
20097
201014
20119
20126
20135
20149
20155
20161
201710
20186
20199
20205
202112
20228
20237
20248
20254

More planes flying means more accidents, so counts aren't a safety score by themselves. Compare the shares above.

Source: NTSB aviation accident database, U.S. accidents 2008–2025. ntsb.gov · Every plane

Updated