The Lemon Index
Mazda MX-5 Miata

Should you buy a Mazda MX-5 Miata?

  • New, the MX-5 Miata 1.6 cost $13,995 (1990 US base list price).
  • Most owner complaints: the 1995 (30). Fewest: the 1993 (8). Raw counts, not per car sold, for every version NHTSA files under this name.
  • Budget for short-nose crankshaft (1990–1991): 1 owner complaint mentions it.
  • Budget for lifter tick: 1 owner complaint mentions it. Consumer Guide says redesigned parts are available.
Sources
  1. Wikipedia: Mazda MX-5 (NA)

What owners say on YouTube

–Not enough videos for a score

Owners praise

Looks19%
Handling and steering19%
Manual gearbox19%
Power and acceleration16%

Owners complain about

Rust11%
Oil leaks (gaskets, seals, housings)11%
Coolant leaks / water pump / overheating10%
Clutch9%

Most-watched videos

  • New, the MX-5 Miata cost $22,098 (2005 cloth model, plus $560 destination; 2001 launch price not found in a Mazda source).
  • Most owner complaints: the 2000 (29). Fewest: the 2005 (4). Raw counts, not per car sold, for every version NHTSA files under this name.
  • Budget for ignition coil faults (2000): 4 owner complaints mention it.
  • Budget for mazdaspeed fuel pump failures: 5 owner complaints mention it.
Sources
  1. Mazda USA: 2005 MX-5 Miata price schedule 2005-3 (Jan 2005)

What owners say on YouTube

48This car's YouTube owner tone, out of 100 · #3 of 3 generations · videos about this generation only (the engine's tone above covers every car with that engine)

Owners praise

Looks22%
Handling and steering21%
Power and acceleration18%
Manual gearbox16%

Owners complain about

Rust9%
Coolant leaks / water pump / overheating9%
Oil leaks (gaskets, seals, housings)7%
Clutch6%

Most-watched videos

  • New, the MX-5 Miata cost $20,435 (2006 Club Spec, plus $560 destination).
  • YouTube likes the 2007 best (60/100).
  • Most owner complaints: the 2006 (25). Fewest: the 2011 (1). Raw counts, not per car sold, for every version NHTSA files under this name.
Sources
  1. Mazda USA: 2006 MX-5 Miata price schedule 2006-1 (Jun 2005)

What owners say on YouTube

57This car's YouTube owner tone, out of 100 · #2 of 3 generations · videos about this generation only (the engine's tone above covers every car with that engine)

Owners praise

Looks22%
Handling and steering21%
Power and acceleration18%
Manual gearbox16%

Owners complain about

Rust9%
Coolant leaks / water pump / overheating9%
Oil leaks (gaskets, seals, housings)7%
Clutch6%

Most-watched videos

  • New, the MX-5 Club cost $29,590 (2019, plus $895 destination; 2025: $33,030).
  • YouTube likes the 2019 best (66/100).
  • Most owner complaints: the 2016 (34). Fewest: the 2021 (1). Raw counts, not per car sold, for every version NHTSA files under this name.
  • Budget for fuel pump recall: 8 owner complaints mention it. Dealer replaces the fuel pump for free (NHTSA 21V-875).
  • Budget for manual gearbox failures (transmission): 8 owner complaints mention it.
Sources
  1. Mazda USA: Enhanced engine, new brown soft top for 2019 MX-5 Miata, with pricing (Oct 2018)

What owners say on YouTube

61This car's YouTube owner tone, out of 100 · #1 of 3 generations · videos about this generation only (the engine's tone above covers every car with that engine)

Owners praise

Looks22%
Handling and steering21%
Power and acceleration18%
Manual gearbox16%

Owners complain about

Rust9%
Coolant leaks / water pump / overheating9%
Oil leaks (gaskets, seals, housings)7%
Clutch6%

Most-watched videos

Updated