The Lemon Index
BMW M3

Should you buy a BMW M3?

  • New, the M3 cost $46,045 (2001 coupe at launch).
  • YouTube likes the 2006 best (54/100).
  • Most owner complaints: the 2003 (54). Fewest: the 2005 (12). Raw counts, not per car sold.
  • Budget for rod bearings: 3 owner complaints mention it. Oil analysis, or preventive bearings (ECS Tuning: about every 100k miles).
  • Budget for vanos: 7 owner complaints mention it. VANOS rebuild with updated hubs.
  • 9 recall campaigns across 2001–2006. Check a VIN before you buy.
Sources
  1. BMW NA press release, Jan 5 2001 (via The Auto Channel)

What owners say on YouTube

53This car's YouTube owner tone, out of 100 · #3 of 4 generations · videos about this generation only (the engine's tone above covers every car with that engine)

Owners praise

Handling and steering23%
Looks19%
Power and acceleration18%
Manual gearbox13%

Owners complain about

Rod bearings11%
VANOS10%
SMG / DCT gearbox10%
Oil leaks (gaskets, seals, housings)8%

Most-watched videos

  • New, the M3 cost $57,275 (2008 coupe; sedan $54,575).
  • YouTube likes the 2011 best (57/100).
  • Most owner complaints: the 2008 (82). Fewest: the 2012 (6). Raw counts, not per car sold.
  • Budget for rod bearings: 30 owner complaints mention it. Preventive bearings around 60,000–80,000 miles (BMWBLOG). Warm the oil first.
  • Budget for throttle actuators: 4 owner complaints mention it. Rebuilt or new actuators, often both at once.
  • 5 recall campaigns across 2008–2013. Check a VIN before you buy.
Sources
  1. BMW NA: 2008 M3 suggested retail prices (Mar 2008)

What owners say on YouTube

53This car's YouTube owner tone, out of 100 · #4 of 4 generations · videos about this generation only (the engine's tone above covers every car with that engine)

Owners praise

Handling and steering14%
Power and acceleration13%
Looks12%
Everyday comfort8%

Owners complain about

Rod bearings12%
SMG / DCT gearbox6%
Throttle actuators6%

Most-watched videos

  • New, the M3 cost $62,000 (plus destination).
  • YouTube likes the 2018 best (56/100).
  • Few owner complaints so far: 21 to NHTSA for 2015–2018.
  • Budget for crank hub: 5 owner complaints mention it. Aftermarket keyed or pinned hub.
  • 4 recall campaigns across 2015–2018. Check a VIN before you buy.
Sources
  1. BMW NA: The all-new BMW M3 Sedan and M4 Coupe (Dec 2013)
  2. BMW NA: M3/M4 pricing guide MY2015 (Jul 2014)

What owners say on YouTube

55This car's YouTube owner tone, out of 100 · #2 of 4 generations · videos about this generation only (the engine's tone above covers every car with that engine)
55Competition Package videos only

Owners praise

Looks25%
Everyday comfort16%
Power and acceleration16%
Handling and steering15%

Owners complain about

Crank hub9%

Most-watched videos

  • New, the M3 Competition cost $72,800 (2021, plus $995 destination).
  • YouTube likes the 2024 best (61/100).
  • Few owner complaints so far: 7 to NHTSA for 2021–2025.
  • 4 recall campaigns across 2021–2025. Check a VIN before you buy.
Sources
  1. BMW NA: The new 2021 BMW M3 Sedan and M4 Coupe

What owners say on YouTube

60This car's YouTube owner tone, out of 100 · #1 of 4 generations · videos about this generation only (the engine's tone above covers every car with that engine)
59M3 Competition videos only

Owners praise

Looks36%
Everyday comfort25%
Power and acceleration25%
Handling and steering25%

Owners complain about

Nothing stands out.

Most-watched videos

Updated