The Lemon Index
Audi S4

Should you buy an Audi S4?

  • New, the S4 sedan cost $37,900 (2000, plus $525 destination).
  • YouTube likes the 2001 best (47/100).
  • Most owner complaints: the 2000 (143). Fewest: the 2002 (22). Raw counts, not per car sold, for every version NHTSA files under this name.
  • Budget for turbo failure: 3 owner complaints mention it. Ask whether the turbos were ever replaced. Owners often do them with the engine out.
  • Budget for valve cover gasket oil leaks: 5 owner complaints mention it. Replace the valve cover gaskets with a full kit, ideally while the engine is out.
  • 1 recall campaign across 2000–2002 (all S4 versions). Check a VIN before you buy.
Sources
  1. Audi of America: Audi's broadest-ever offering, 2000 model-year pricing (Sep 1999, via The Auto Channel)

What owners say on YouTube

45This car's YouTube owner tone, out of 100 · #5 of 5 generations · videos about this generation only (the engine's tone above covers every car with that engine)

Owners praise

Power and acceleration10%
Handling and steering9%
Looks7%
Everyday comfort6%

Owners complain about

Spark plugs / coils / misfire7%
Oil leaks (gaskets, seals, housings)7%
Rust7%

Most-watched videos

  • YouTube likes the 2004 best (51/100).
  • Most owner complaints: the 2005 (43). Fewest: the 2004 (29). Raw counts, not per car sold, for every version NHTSA files under this name.
  • Budget for timing chain guides and tensioners: 8 owner complaints mention it. Owners report the engine has to come out for the job, with bills around $5,000–$7,000.
  • Budget for mechanical cam adjuster: 1 owner complaint mentions it. It is replaced as part of a timing chain service kit.
  • 3 recall campaigns across 2004–2005 (all S4 versions). Check a VIN before you buy.

What owners say on YouTube

50This car's YouTube owner tone, out of 100 · #3 of 5 generations · videos about this generation only (the engine's tone above covers every car with that engine)

Owners praise

Looks6%
Power and acceleration5%

Owners complain about

Oil leaks (gaskets, seals, housings)6%
Timing chain / tensioners6%
Timing chain guides6%

Most-watched videos

  • YouTube likes the 2007 best (50/100).
  • Most owner complaints: the 2006 (30). Fewest: the 2008 (4). Raw counts, not per car sold, for every version NHTSA files under this name.
  • Budget for timing chain guides and tensioners: 1 owner complaint mentions it. Owners report the engine has to come out for the job, with bills around $5,000–$7,000.
  • 2 recall campaigns across 2006–2008 (all S4 versions). Check a VIN before you buy.

What owners say on YouTube

49This car's YouTube owner tone, out of 100 · #4 of 5 generations · videos about this generation only (the engine's tone above covers every car with that engine)

Owners praise

Looks6%
Power and acceleration5%

Owners complain about

Oil leaks (gaskets, seals, housings)6%
Timing chain / tensioners6%
Timing chain guides6%

Most-watched videos

  • New, the S4 (6-speed manual) cost $45,900 (2010; destination not stated).
  • YouTube likes the 2013 best (58/100).
  • Most owner complaints: the 2010 (60). Fewest: the 2015 (1). Raw counts, not per car sold, for every version NHTSA files under this name.
  • Budget for fuel rail leak recall (2011–2012): 2 owner complaints mention it. Dealer replaces the fuel rails and seals for free (NHTSA 15V-019).
  • Budget for water pump leaks: 11 owner complaints mention it. Replace the pump. The seller also advises a new pump after any overheating.
  • 2 recall campaigns across 2010–2016 (all S4 versions). Check a VIN before you buy.
Sources
  1. Motor Authority: Supercharged 2010 Audi S4 sedan starts from $45,900 (Aug 2009)
  2. Motor Authority: Driven, 2010 Audi S4 (Jun 2010)

What owners say on YouTube

54This car's YouTube owner tone, out of 100 · #2 of 5 generations · videos about this generation only (the engine's tone above covers every car with that engine)

Owners praise

Handling and steering14%
Interior and seats14%
Power and acceleration13%
Looks11%

Owners complain about

Coolant leaks / water pump / overheating7%
Water pump / thermostat5%

Most-watched videos

  • New, the S4 cost $51,875 (2018 Premium Plus; destination not stated).
  • YouTube likes the 2024 best (58/100).
  • Most owner complaints: the 2020 (17). Fewest: the 2022 (1). Raw counts, not per car sold, for every version NHTSA files under this name.
  • Budget for water pump and coolant module leaks: 1 owner complaint mentions it. A parts seller says the plastic impeller can come off the shaft, and lists the pump at $300–$500 plus labor.
  • Budget for pcv diaphragm in the valve cover: 1 owner complaint mentions it. Replace the valve cover, which holds the PCV; listed at $800–$1,300.
  • 7 recall campaigns across 2018–2025 (all S4 versions). Check a VIN before you buy.
Sources
  1. Motor Authority: 2018 Audi S4 preview (Feb 2017)

What owners say on YouTube

56This car's YouTube owner tone, out of 100 · #1 of 5 generations · videos about this generation only (the engine's tone above covers every car with that engine)

Owners praise

Looks26%
Handling and steering20%
Interior and seats19%
Everyday comfort19%

Owners complain about

Nothing stands out.

Most-watched videos

Updated